Mario Sundar

LinkedIn's 2nd PR hire. These are my thoughts on products, public relations, and startups.

iPhone vs. Kindle: Who Won?

Quick Update: Perfect timing. The Boy Genius Report just outed some pics of the second version of the Kindle. The form factor is definitely an improvement over the original, so those wanting to buy a Kindle may want to wait for a bit. Check out the post. (pics here)

Boy Genius Report)

Kindle vs. Kindle 2 (Source: Boy Genius Report)

Back to my original post.

As readers of this blog know, I’ve been pretty outspoken in my feelings about the Kindle vs. iPhone debate in the past, going so far as saying: the future of reading is the iPhone, NOT the Kindle. My 2nd post on this topic written more than half a year later, gathered an evolved consensus on where that comparison between the iPhone and Kindle stood.

iPhone vs. Kindle

Original iPhone vs. Kindle comparison

And, it’s official now – the iPhone (despite being a music/browser/phone/app platform) has bested the Amazon’s Kindle at it’s own game – in sheer # of readers!

Stanza, a book reading app on the iPhone, is close to ~400K downloads at a current rate of ~5K downloads per day, while the Kindle is estimated to sell ~380K devices this year. And, let’s not get started on the # of iPhones sold as of date and the passionate following they have acquired.

But, since this is an apples and oranges comparison, let’s look at the major differences between the devices:

1. Price: While the Stanza is free if you already own the iPhone, the Kindle is twice as expensive (~$399) than the iPhone (~199)

2. Book Selection: Definitely the Kindle. It’s Amazon and they have the greatest selection of books on the planet.

3. Reading experience: I love reading on my iPhone. I’ve spent hours reading my Google Reader feeds, but Kindle is rumored to be easier on the eyes, thanks to E-Ink.

4. Battery Life: My biggest pet peeve with the iPhone is the battery life (particularly since it’s an essential utility in my life). It lasts for a day. The Kindle’s battery lasts for four days.

5. Connectivity: Again, the iPhone works flawlessly with Wi-Fi (spotty 3G networks hamper the 3G experience), and I’ve just the right apps to make even my Edge experience bearable. The Kindle: EV-DO.

As you can see, if you’re a voracious reader, the Kindle is your best bet – looks notwithstanding (although I think it’s a really expensive purchase). But, as the Forbes article pointed out:

Stanza users are a different type of reader from Kindle buyers, says Feedbooks Chief Executive Hadrien Gardeur. “Kindle appeals to heavy readers who spend far more time reading than anyone who uses an iPhone,” he says. “But I don’t think the mass market is ready to spend that kind of money. So they really don’t compete with one another at this point.”

But the iPhone definitely has the potential to become a huge hit among average book readers (going by the numbers) and I presume there are many like me – “1 book a month” readers. So, if Jobs can recreate the iTunes ecosystem for books, I’ll pay for the books. And, so will millions of other satisfied iPhone users.

Are you an iPhone or a Kindle? Or do you prefer reading books the old-fashioned way?

Sign up to receive Marketing Nirvana posts either in your RSS reader or Email Inbox (Subscribe now!)

Filed under: Miscellaneous

13 Responses

  1. WebUrs says:

    I prefer reading things the old fashioned way, I just feel that taking a book to bed is a nicer experience than a Kindle …. its also easier on my eyes.

    Like

  2. Jack Baty says:

    ” but Kindle is rumored to be easier on the eyes, thanks to E-Ink.”

    Rumored? Use a Kindle for 30 minutes and you’ll never want to read on the iPhone again. The iPhone and the Kindle have a few overlapping features, but for actually reading more than a few blog articles, the Kindle experience is so much better I’m not sure I’d bother even making a comparison.

    I love my iPhone too, and read things on it all the time. It’s not the same.

    Like

  3. Abbas Haider Ali says:

    I used stanza on a biz trip for the 1st time yesterday. Great except that I can’t use it during taxi and landing which was torture. I like the kindles screen more for reading for longer periods of time.

    Ideally, amazon would offer a kindle iPhone app so that I have both breadth of content and convenience of carrying around just one device.

    Like

  4. Mario Sundar says:

    Well, Jack, I’ll take your word for it. I haven’t tested it out yet.

    @Abbas,

    Frankly, I haven’t read an entire book on Stanza yet. I love the idea of an Amazon app on the iPhone, but I don’t see that happening any time.

    Like

  5. Josh Neumann says:

    Neither. Ditto the above post.

    Like

  6. PP says:

    I’ve read on the Kindle and while it’s nice to read on, I didn’t feel it was that much better and certainly not in the dark. With the iphone’s ability to invert the black to white, I can read in the dark without disturbing my wife. I have a bunch of great books from ereader.com. Plus I have my calendar, music, movies, news, internet, email, bible, calculator, dictionary, electronic wallet, instant messenger, and so much more in my pocket. I certainly don’t want to spend $360 on a not so attractive that can’t fit in my pocket, doesn’t have a backlight, or even a fraction of the features.

    Like

  7. […] Kindle v2.0 (more aesthetically pleasing – not an eyesore), the desire to centralize all my reading in one simple device vs. a life of strewn unread books, battery life, lower price point expected (between $249 to $299), but most importantly the fact that nobody has a better, more complete catalog of books on the planet than Amazon. In much the same way as Apple currently reigns supreme in the music business, thanks to iTunes. […]

    Like

  8. There definitely isn’t an “Amazon” app for the iPhone. In fact, Amazon is (apparently) preventing Mobipocket, whom they own, from releasing an official Mobipocket client for the iPhone—meaning people with DRM-crippled Mobipocket format books have to crack the DRM if they want to read them on the Mobi-compatible readers on the iPhone.

    Like

  9. […] article compares the Kindle with the 32G iPod touch but I’d rather compare it to the iPhone 3g as I’ve in the past and can safely conclude that if you’re a bibliophile, the Kindle […]

    Like

  10. Steve says:

    The Kindle seems silly to buy when the iPhone is so much smaller. With the iPhone, you literally CAN take thousands of book anywhere, because you can fit it in your pocket. With the Kindle, you have to hold the dang thing in your hand everywhere you go.

    Like

    • Mario Sundar says:

      @Steve,

      Agreed. But, if you’re into reading books there’s no substitute for a Kindle (as much as I love the iPhone). I just bought the Kindle and it rocks too!

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s